Meet Our Team


At Judd Shaw Injury Law™, we understand that after an accident, you are going through one of the most stressful times of your life. You deserve help from a law firm that has years of combined experience handling New Jersey and New York injury claims.

Our team is ready to help you and your family through every step of the legal process. Let us answer your questions, handle the paperwork, and negotiate with the insurance company to get you the best possible results, so you can focus on recovering from your injuries.

Paul Brockie

Chief Financial Officer

Kevin Mulligan

Lead Attorney
Personal Injury Litigation

John Ernst

Associate Attorney
No-Fault PIP Arbitration

Brooke Wheaton

Associate Attorney
Personal Injury Litigation

Ivonne Toscano

Intake Manager
No-Fault PIP Arbitration

Alexis DeMatteo

Intake Manager
Personal Injury

Amy O’Shea

Finance Manager

Michael Triano Davis

Claims Manager
Personal Injury Pre-Litigation

Dali Garcia

Personal Injury Intake Lead

Ellie Tamez

Claims Manager
Personal Injury Pre-Litigation

Carolyn Lita

Paralegal

Frank Ballos

Paralegal

Anthony Sarci

Pre-Litigation Support Specialist

Robert Bella

Director of Administration

Kate Canty

No-Fault Intake Lead

Morgan Lavalla

Claims Manager

Nicholas Shirley

Support Manager
Personal Injury Litigation